Home > News > Headlines

Print   Subscribe

Turtle Talk: Thoughts on land-into-trust decision
Wednesday, February 25, 2009
Filed Under: Law | Opinion

"A couple of quick thoughts on this case:

1.) This does NOT affect tribes that were acknowledged by the United States at or before the time the IRA was enacted in 1934. You’re safe from this one - the Secretary can still consider your fee-to-trust applications.

2.) This does NOT affect fee-to-trust acquisitions that have already occurred for tribes recognized after 1934. The Federal Quiet Title Act does not allow challenges to federal land acquisitions after the fact, except in limited circumstances not applicable in this case. In other words, if your tribe was recognized after 1934 and has reservation land already in trust, that land is safe.

3.) This SHOULD NOT affect fee-to-trust applications that are pending, or in the future, for tribes acknowledged in 1934, terminated after that date, and re-acknowledged. (I say “should not,” because the tribe should be able to successfully argue that it was under federal jurisdiction in 1934 - but the Supreme Court has done damage to tribes with less before).

4.) This DOES affect pending or future fee-to-trust applications for tribes that were not acknowledged until after 1934. Those tribes will now have to prove they were “under federal jurisdiction” in 1934. The term “under federal jurisdiction” does not necessarily mean that the tribe had to be federally recognized in 1934 (in fact, I would argue that ALL recognized tribes, regardless of when recognition/acknowledgment occurred, were under federal jurisdiction in 1934). The Court seems to have left this one open - for now. This will place yet another litigation obstacle in front of tribes as they seek to have land placed into trust."

Get the Story:
Initial Reaction to Carcieri Opinion (Turtle Talk 2/24)

Supreme Court Decision:
Carcieri v. Salazar (February 24, 2009)

Supreme Court Documents:
Oral Argument Transcript | Briefs

Related Stories:
Supreme Court rules in big land-into-trust case (2/25)
Turtle Talk: Decision brewing in land-into-trust case (01/22)
Land-into-trust case rejected by Supreme Court (1/22)
Land-into-trust case awaits Supreme Court action (1/13)
Turtle Talk: More thoughts on land-into-trust cases (01/13)
Supreme Court rejects two Indian law cases (1/12)
DOJ brief argues 1934 land-into-trust issue again (12/16)
Supreme Court takes on first Indian law case of term (11/04)
Turtle Talk: Poor outlook on land-into-trust case (11/4)
Rhode Island optimistic on land-into-trust case (11/04)
Oregon tribes await outcome of land-into-trust case (11/04)
Appeals court delays casino for Michigan tribe (8/18)
Appeals court judge strikes blows against Indian rights (5/5)
Appeals court backs Gun Lake land-into-trust (4/29)
Appeals court backs Michigan land-into-trust acquisition (7/5)
Appeals court sides with tribe in trust land dispute (1/9)

Copyright © Indianz.Com